Red Dead Redemption vs. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Graphics Comparison (SPOILERS)


კომენტარები • 480

  • I'm Back
    I'm Back 18 დღის წინ

    Feels like they remastered RDR

  • Paul Willems
    Paul Willems 18 დღის წინ

    I never played the first one but I definitely thought this was a joke video at first. There were definitely some shots were the first one looked a hundred times better

  • Edgar Ramirez
    Edgar Ramirez 24 დღის წინ

    Name song?

  • xlSneak-_
    xlSneak-_ 25 დღის წინ

    Best game ever created!

  • W Parker
    W Parker 25 დღის წინ

    I hope you can still ride bulls online.

  • Stephen Beddoe
    Stephen Beddoe 26 დღის წინ

    why does a graphics comparison need to contain spoilers??

  • RObin Solon
    RObin Solon 26 დღის წინ


  • ghazan khan
    ghazan khan 27 დღის წინ +1

    i love everything about red dead 2 except their graphics

  • Yungstar
    Yungstar 27 დღის წინ

    if nothing else, it shows how powerful 360 was with its 512mb of mem over the X's 8GB+.

  • Shaqstheman000
    Shaqstheman000 27 დღის წინ

    RDR1 aged better than I expected.

  • Potienza
    Potienza 27 დღის წინ

    I miss the vibrant and lively Armadillo from RDR1 though ... :(

  • Amanda Fernandes
    Amanda Fernandes 27 დღის წინვიდეო.html RED DEAD REDEMPTION TUDO SOBRE

  • noelgt101
    noelgt101 27 დღის წინ

    I prefer johns walk in red dead 1. More swag to it.

  • brandon mora
    brandon mora 27 დღის წინ +1

    i think i liked Rdd more

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 20 დღის წინ

      brandon mora yeah. And mgs1 looks better than mgs5 amirite?

  • MediaHypeTrain
    MediaHypeTrain 27 დღის წინ

    Can’t wait til the PC release so we can remove the annoying grey tint over RDR2

  • MegaPlayDoe
    MegaPlayDoe 27 დღის წინ

    I had more fun playing red dead 1 if I’m being honest lol

  • Lachlan Reynen
    Lachlan Reynen 28 დღის წინ

    I hope rockstar makes a undead nightmare for red dead redemption 2

  • sethman75
    sethman75 28 დღის წინ

    RDR1 is the better game by a long shot.

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 19 დღის წინ

      sethman75 in what aspect?

    • sethman75
      sethman75 19 დღის წინ

      +Th1s Justin No but i think RDR1 is far better than RDR2.

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 20 დღის წინ

      sethman75 “by a long shot”. Lmao okay. Do you also believe that pong is the best game of all time?

  • sefter454
    sefter454 28 დღის წინ

    RDR 1's graphics still hold up even if slightly outdated. The game has aged very well.

  • ProbablyFear
    ProbablyFear 28 დღის წინ

    Looks like PS4 vs Xbox to me

  • Niki Tr
    Niki Tr 28 დღის წინ

    I've got a ps4 pro but tbh the xbox one X backwards compatibility is much better than our ps now....

  • kabrawl jr
    kabrawl jr 28 დღის წინ


  • Sam Dragneel
    Sam Dragneel 28 დღის წინ

    I think Rock 🌟 should surprise their fans with a Rdr Remake just like CapCom did it with RE2

  • aligamerable
    aligamerable 28 დღის წინ

    One thing that bugs me a little, John uses Arthur's walking and running animation. Not the ones he have in RDR1

  • Grant Watson
    Grant Watson 28 დღის წინ

    So the first one looks better than the second one.

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 20 დღის წინ

      Grant Watson hot take alert

  • Cristóbal Duchén
    Cristóbal Duchén 28 დღის წინ

    I love how they remade Armadillo...
    Too bad there's really nothing to do there besides buying things from the store or drinking in the saloon.

  • Mad Man
    Mad Man 28 დღის წინ

    So ign decides to make a video comparing a 2018 Ps4 game to a 2010 ps3 game

  • SYT94828 Gaming
    SYT94828 Gaming 28 დღის წინ +1

    RDR1 has better graphics than PUBG.

  • Влад
    Влад 28 დღის წინ +2

    Now that is RDR1 was ahead of its time, it’s my favorite game of past gen. And now RDR2 is my favorite game of current gen.

  • Joao Rodrigues
    Joao Rodrigues 28 დღის წინ

    What is the name of this soundtrack?

  • Sharctic
    Sharctic 28 დღის წინ

    So nice

  • GeetInDVan
    GeetInDVan 28 დღის წინ

    _Unlike a lot of 2010 games, RDR1 aged pretty well in all aspects, especially in terms of graphics..._

  • ColdSilentNinja
    ColdSilentNinja 28 დღის წინ

    Both are awesome

  • Sokratis Anagnostopoulos
    Sokratis Anagnostopoulos 28 დღის წინ


  • Amal Jude Joseph
    Amal Jude Joseph 28 დღის წინ

    What's the difference?

  • Genius Nigam
    Genius Nigam 28 დღის წინ

    This game is the best looking game on console!

  • Duwang King
    Duwang King 28 დღის წინ

    I would like to see a remaster of Red Dead Redemption 1!

  • Conorama
    Conorama 28 დღის წინ

    Can someone explain this..
    I havent completed the story yet but i already know that you end up playing as john, but if john is already living in beechers hope at the end of rdr2, how is it that he arrives of the boat in blackwater at the start of rdr1?
    Is there a untold story as too if he went back to say Saint Denis, how did he get in contact with Edgar ross to meet him in blackwater if he already lived in beechers hope?

    • eatablecookie858
      eatablecookie858 28 დღის წინ

      Edgar ross tracked him down, you can see edgar ross and his partner finding clues and tracking John down to beecher's hope. Don't know about the boat though.

  • glenjamin88
    glenjamin88 28 დღის წინ

    Really shows how broken the game is looking with HDR all washed out compared to nice crisp picture of the 8 year old game

  • Ethan Wagner
    Ethan Wagner 28 დღის წინ +3

    Wow, rockstar in 2010 is better than Bethesda in 2018

  • A Dude Named Requis
    A Dude Named Requis 28 დღის წინ

    What was the music at the end?

  • peruface
    peruface 28 დღის წინ

    2010 looks better tho

  • Hannibal Sahura
    Hannibal Sahura 28 დღის წინ +1

    One looks better on most to me

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 20 დღის წინ

      Hannibal Sahura in what aspect does it look better? Please tell me

  • The Burger King
    The Burger King 28 დღის წინ

    I wish they gave John armbands to swim in rdr2

  • The Burger King
    The Burger King 28 დღის წინ

    New Austin feels quite empty in Red Dead Redemption 2, which does make sense because we’ve already explored that map and rockstar want to focus mostly on the new map.

  • RonZombie91
    RonZombie91 28 დღის წინ +1

    Why post spoiler videos? Why not compare other aspects? Tf?

    • RonZombie91
      RonZombie91 27 დღის წინ

      +AbzorTCryteK I can read. That's not my point. For those of us who haven't beaten the game and want to see the comparison.

    • AbzorTCryteK
      AbzorTCryteK 27 დღის წინ

      It says spoiler alert.

  • Fanatic Potato
    Fanatic Potato 28 დღის წინ

    did you capture the RDR1 footage on a XBone X with the 4K enhancement turned on?

  • Cinematic Theatre
    Cinematic Theatre 28 დღის წინ

    I really wish they’d let me play as Arthur again though. I can’t wear any of my outfits on John because it just doesn’t look right and I miss that big brown beard and country way about him. I don’t want to reload the save though because I’ve done so much as John.

  • Ashfaq Khazi
    Ashfaq Khazi 28 დღის წინ +1

    RDR1 has aged pretty well
    It's amazing how, over the years, Rockstar has managed to top their past games.
    Kudos to them
    Clearly the best games developer of all time

  • David Malone
    David Malone 28 დღის წინ

    Yall couldn’t make this without adding spoilers?

  • Zerdical
    Zerdical 28 დღის წინ

    What animal makes this noise? 0:11

  • Big Belly69
    Big Belly69 28 დღის წინ

    John > Arthur

  • Brandon J Larry Gaming
    Brandon J Larry Gaming 28 დღის წინ

    Is it me or does new Austin in rdr2 looks a little bit smaller ?

  • saltibagos tsoupakabras
    saltibagos tsoupakabras 28 დღის წინ +1

    Just think for a second how rdr2 will look on pc !!!

  • Mac Marston
    Mac Marston 28 დღის წინ

    I hope Rock will remaster red dead 1 as a red dead 2 dlc

    STORM GOWARD 28 დღის წინ

    false alarm! here not no one spoller!

  • DR Mantis Toboggan
    DR Mantis Toboggan 28 დღის წინ +3

    I want RDR1 DLC..........

  • DR Mantis Toboggan
    DR Mantis Toboggan 28 დღის წინ +122

    8 year old game looks better than Fallout 76.....................

    • Austin
      Austin 28 დღის წინ +3

      And that's an understatement to say the least

    • Bivo Gaming Squad
      Bivo Gaming Squad 28 დღის წინ +3


  • David
    David 28 დღის წინ

    This should be longer! Loads more locations like Fort Mercer have been remastered. Does anyone know how much of New Austin is missing from RDR2, or is it a 1:1 remaster (talking about map layout/general locations). This video has made it seem as if it is.

  • Adam Brooks
    Adam Brooks 28 დღის წინ +1

    Finally a graphics comparison video where there's an obvious difference!.. But RDR1 still looks great!

  • Calvin Matthews
    Calvin Matthews 28 დღის წინ

    Is it me or RDR age pretty damn well?

  • deathmetal weedman
    deathmetal weedman 28 დღის წინ

    im not watching this video becouse im waiting for the PC version

  • Vicente Nevarez
    Vicente Nevarez 28 დღის წინ

    So red dead revolver dont count,without that there wouldn't be no redemption

  • Owen Boyle
    Owen Boyle 28 დღის წინ

    fallout 76 review pls

  • Gabriel Kelly
    Gabriel Kelly 28 დღის წინ +1

    We need a red dead remastered edition. But bully 2 first

  • Gothboy
    Gothboy 28 დღის წინ

    I love looking for smoke in the air. Helps when you have no HUD

  • Nathan Lestini
    Nathan Lestini 28 დღის წინ

    I hope if they make a 3rd it goes back to the gangs formation and very early days, when the West was truly “wild” let us switch between Arthur and John almost like GTA’s character switch component.

    • jesse burrows
      jesse burrows 28 დღის წინ

      +John Arild Ramberg no it's not. Red dead is a singular focus, you're actually the side character in red dead 2 the whole story was about Dutch ...

    • John Arild Ramberg
      John Arild Ramberg 28 დღის წინ

      Thats actually a great idea

  • karma tam
    karma tam 28 დღის წინ

    I bought red dead redemption demotion to play undead nightmare
    Was so disappointed I had to buy the other version

  • Torchwoodandwesterns
    Torchwoodandwesterns 28 დღის წინ

    The 60 hour game has only been out 3 weeks why do a graphics comparison with spoilers in it xD

    • Torchwoodandwesterns
      Torchwoodandwesterns 28 დღის წინ

      James {-} honestly IGN should just hire me

    • Torchwoodandwesterns
      Torchwoodandwesterns 28 დღის წინ

      James {-} I meant the majority of people won’t have completed the game yet so why put spoilers in a graphics comparison video when you could just use scenic shots

    • James {-}
      James {-} 28 დღის წინ


  • desi williams
    desi williams 29 დღის წინ +8

    The Graphics wasn’t to bad back then

    • Colin Nolan
      Colin Nolan 28 დღის წინ

      desi williams iVery Smart, bb

    • desi williams
      desi williams 28 დღის წინ

      Colin 😂😂 I can tell your bored asf keep on trolling I have no energy for you nothing is wrong with ether comment you just wanna seem smart I guess 🤷🏾‍♂️

    • Colin Nolan
      Colin Nolan 28 დღის წინ

      desi williamsვიდეო.html

    • Colin Nolan
      Colin Nolan 28 დღის წინ

      desi williams both your comments are edited and still bad

  • Nick Filion
    Nick Filion 29 დღის წინ

    Not a lot of desert in this game's storyline sadly

  • Doppel Ganger
    Doppel Ganger 29 დღის წინ

    Graphics looks amazing for both games

  • Ellis Scott
    Ellis Scott 29 დღის წინ +2

    First game looks incredible for 8 years old

  • phraze
    phraze 29 დღის წინ +64

    I think it would be smart making a DLC that is RDR1. They already have the whole New Austin map in RDR2. And there is alot of detail if you glitch over to Mexico too. They don't even need to record the dialogue, they can just use the original. It would be a lot less work, and it would sell like hell!

    • nmysights01
      nmysights01 25 დღის წინ

      The biggest issue with this that I could see is the time period. The 1907 version has a lot of components that weren't in the 1911 version, and vice versa. There are so many things that would have to be changed to accommodate the original story, plus they would probably have to age the new map in some way. They would also have to update at least some of the dialogue to include events and characters from RDR2.

    • trev2x
      trev2x 27 დღის წინ

      I think they will. They didn’t put New Austin on the game for no damn reason....

    • Twisted-Chimp
      Twisted-Chimp 28 დღის წინ

      Dude that's basically asking for an entire game stack on top of another, so it wouldn't be so simple, as they would have to remake all the cutscenes, as well as the fact, RDR 2 is already a Tad to powerful for our current gen consoles, so adding an entire game on top of it, just wouldn't work

    • PCGaming
      PCGaming 28 დღის წინ

      +Jonas D. that guy does my head in

    ITS A DIO 29 დღის წინ

    I love both games. They are gold.

  • Dutch Van Der Linde
    Dutch Van Der Linde 29 დღის წინ

    Lmaoo who compare 2010 game vs 2018 game ofc its better now

    • Bigman Gamer
      Bigman Gamer 28 დღის წინ

      Because they both share the same worldspace

  • Burleon
    Burleon 29 დღის წინ +4

    The desert storms look hella better in rdr2 I was so happy with a better looking Armadillo

    • Burleon
      Burleon 20 დღის წინ

      +Th1s Justin thanks pal

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 20 დღის წინ

      Burleon finally somebody with there nostalgia glasses off

  • Jac Boz
    Jac Boz 29 დღის წინ

    How do you get John Marston's cloths in rd2?

    • Milbox R
      Milbox R 29 დღის წინ

      Story missions

  • yasashii89
    yasashii89 29 დღის წინ

    Both games look like they're for the same console

  • Mason Johnson
    Mason Johnson 29 დღის წინ

    ... Ign so dumb they need to put spoiler in there video for not being able to get open world gameplay footage ......

  • raik z
    raik z 29 დღის წინ +2

    Red dead is better than red dead 2
    Try to argue with me

    • the last of us
      the last of us 26 დღის წინ


    • LzysGraphics
      LzysGraphics 28 დღის წინ

      raik z But revolved ain't an open world game man

  • bushki
    bushki 29 დღის წინ +104

    i think this proves how ahead of its time RDR1 was

    • Erik Sivec
      Erik Sivec 27 დღის წინ

      +LzysGraphics it goes same with gta 4. which released 2 years earlier

    • LzysGraphics
      LzysGraphics 28 დღის წინ

      Crisis lmao

    • bruno jorge
      bruno jorge 28 დღის წინ +1

      +Endangered Mexican it's still one of the best looking game in 2018

  • Kostas Spirou
    Kostas Spirou 29 დღის წინ +30

    Red Dead Redemption 1 aged very well 👌.

    • Brendan Greene
      Brendan Greene 27 დღის წინ +1

      Apart from the nighttime sky, which I think looks like mud.

    YOUR GOD 29 დღის წინ +1

    0:31 let me guess, your game
    Yes and it was beautiful

    • YOUR GOD
      YOUR GOD 20 დღის წინ

      +Th1s Justin thank you

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 20 დღის წინ +1

      rant osaurus this deserves way more likes lmao

    YOUR GOD 29 დღის წინ

    This doesn't need to be a competition like which one you think.

  • !BEASTY!
    !BEASTY! 29 დღის წინ +1

    Does anyone know if/ when the soundtrack is out?

  • Dridge
    Dridge 29 დღის წინ

    Rd2 has more weather effect, better lighting, better AA, textures, blah blah blah anyone seeing 1 being better is caked with nostalgia.

  • thewewguy8t88
    thewewguy8t88 29 დღის წინ +1

    its honestly hard to say which game looks better cuz they both look great.

  • ChickenMemeG
    ChickenMemeG 29 დღის წინ +11

    people here saying the first game looks better need 2 pairs of glasses one xbox one/ps4 and rdr2, you clearly didn't play the 2 games.

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 20 დღის წინ

      Gideon Garner he might as well say that mario 64 looks better

    • Young Edge
      Young Edge 27 დღის წინ

      They are joking lol, even my 5 years old brother knew which is better looking

    • Niki Tr
      Niki Tr 28 დღის წინ

      Gideon Garner naah gta 3 looks far better

    • Gideon Garner
      Gideon Garner 28 დღის წინ

      thewewguy8t88 might as well say bully looks better

  • Basit Saliu
    Basit Saliu 29 დღის წინ +1

    1899 vs 1911; 2018 vs 2011.

  • James Lopez
    James Lopez 29 დღის წინ +16

    RD2 looks hazy AF compared to the 1st. Definitely better but not as much as I would have expected

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 20 დღის წინ

      James Lopez you’re totally not just saying this because it was the first game

    • abdul nayeem
      abdul nayeem 28 დღის წინ


    • Genius Nigam
      Genius Nigam 28 დღის წინ

      You should say that for every game then, since rdr 2 is currently the best looking game in consoles

    • That guy
      That guy 28 დღის წინ

      Its just the compression. this is why when you watch e3 stuff on youtube its doesnt look that great or trailers for that matter.

      STAgGYNITE 29 დღის წინ +8

      It looks undeniably godlike on my xbox one x and 4k tv

  • Gambello
    Gambello 29 დღის წინ +4

    Original RDR looks way better

  • mtchyb
    mtchyb 29 დღის წინ +190

    Not gonna lie. Red Dead Redemption was far ahead of it's time in 2010. Today it's still very playable, especially with the new HD retexture that Rockstar recently released.

    • AbzorTCryteK
      AbzorTCryteK 27 დღის წინ

      +mtchyb Its exactly like how Wii u emulators can play Breath of the Wild in 4K resolution 60 FPS on PC (better than even Nintendo latest console the switch) . It's exactly like that but on a bigger scale, officially, and legally.

    • AbzorTCryteK
      AbzorTCryteK 27 დღის წინ

      +mtchyb I'm not disputing anything I showed facts saying how this wasn't Rockstar but Microsoft's doing like the 2 other people said above me . If you read both articles they talk about how they upgrade a game with the power of the Xbox One and Xbox One X (That isn't thier own). It really isnt hard to do. The games released on their console. All they need is the rights to do this.

    • mtchyb
      mtchyb 27 დღის წინ

      +AbzorTCryteK I don't see why you feel the need to dispute this. Microsoft wouldn't be able to go through and re-texture a game that isn't theirs. Also, considering the fact that the entire RD1 map is inside of RD2, I think it is obvious that Rockstar had a hand in brushing up the graphics.

    • AbzorTCryteK
      AbzorTCryteK 27 დღის წინ

      +mtchyb I'm pretty sure all Backwards Compatibility is almost all Microsoft's doing (unless a studio wants to help if they're still alive) since a lot of these companies are shut down or don't have the necessary developer tools to edit such games anymore. They could do every single game on all their consoles and upscale them if they had permission and rights to the games contents.

  • Penguin
    Penguin 29 დღის წინ +17

    Wtf would you put spoilers in a graphics comparison video...

    • SkiMask II
      SkiMask II 28 დღის წინ

      It's in the title...

      BOLT ACTION 28 დღის წინ +1

      It legit said that their are spoilers dude. Like cmon !

    • Waffle Buster
      Waffle Buster 28 დღის წინ

      Mustapha El Saytari Yes you can even change into authors old clothes and hat and you’ll get everything he had except for the money

    • Diego Michel
      Diego Michel 28 დღის წინ

      Penguin but if they can compare the same locations then why wouldn’t they 😂

    • An unimportant comment
      An unimportant comment 28 დღის წინ

      Wtf get over it lmao

  • Jose Moran
    Jose Moran 29 დღის წინ +2

    I haven't play neither of them but red redemption 1 looks great and more appealing

  • Brock Gundich
    Brock Gundich 29 დღის წინ

    Is no one gonna question why armadillo is on fire?

    • The sneaky Socialist
      The sneaky Socialist 29 დღის წინ

      They're burning bodies because of a cholera outbreak.

  • Ak47
    Ak47 29 დღის წინ

    rdr1 more grittier

  • SupremeLLama
    SupremeLLama 29 დღის წინ +3

    Why does the RDR1 look better in some cases?🤔

    • Th1s Justin
      Th1s Justin 20 დღის წინ

      Prasanna Venkat thank you

    • Prasanna Venkat
      Prasanna Venkat 27 დღის წინ +1

      Because you didn't take off your nostalgic glasses when watching this video

    • SupremeLLama
      SupremeLLama 28 დღის წინ

      +BOLT ACTION fax

      BOLT ACTION 28 დღის წინ +2

      If u play the game on your tv then the game looks godlike compared to rdr 1. But rdr1 has aged well.

  • aliyu idris
    aliyu idris 29 დღის წინ

    What is wrong with you folks at ign. How can you compare graphics of games that are 8 years apart.

  • Nolay Austin
    Nolay Austin 29 დღის წინ +1

    What a difference 8 years makes